DLX

Deluxe Corp ($DLX) Executives Keep Buying Despite 30% Stock Plunge, Analysts See 100% Upside

06/12/2025 14:29

Deluxe Corp ($DLX) has been drawing market attention as its executives continue purchasing shares despite a significant stock price decline in 2025. While the stock has plummeted over 30% from $22 to the $14-15 range since February, President Barry McCarthy and SVP William Zint have maintained consistent buying patterns, signaling potential confidence in the company's future prospects. Most recently, SVP Zint purchased 175 shares at $15.88 per share on June 11, following his established 10b5-1 trading plan adopted in December 2023. This follows President McCarthy's substantial purchase of 3,926 shares at $16.45 per share in March, representing over $64,000 in investment during a period of significant stock decline. Founded in 1915, Deluxe Corp has evolved from a traditional check printing company into a comprehensive business services provider. The company now offers digital payment solutions, cloud-based business tools, and promotional products, targeting small and medium-sized businesses. Key competitors include Paychex and ADP, with Deluxe positioning itself as a one-stop business solutions provider for the SMB market. The consistency of insider purchases during the stock's decline is particularly noteworthy. President McCarthy has made four separate purchases totaling approximately $230,000 from June 2024 through March 2025, while SVP Zint has maintained regular smaller purchases throughout the same period. All transactions were executed pursuant to pre-established 10b5-1 plans, indicating systematic investment strategy rather than opportunistic trading based on material non-public information. Deluxe's recent financial performance shows resilience in profitability despite revenue headwinds. Fourth quarter 2024 revenue declined 3.1% year-over-year to $520.5 million, but adjusted earnings per share of 84 cents exceeded analyst expectations of 83 cents. The first quarter of 2025 showed signs of revenue stabilization with a 0.3% increase to $536.5 million, though EPS of 75 cents fell slightly short of the previous year's 76 cents. Wall Street analysts maintain a 'buy' rating on Deluxe with a median 12-month price target of $29, representing approximately 100% upside from current levels. However, the market appears skeptical about the company's digital transformation pace and the growth potential of its newer business segments, creating a significant disconnect between analyst expectations and current valuation. Industry experts note that while Deluxe is successfully transitioning toward digital solutions and cloud-based services, the company faces challenges in fully offsetting declining traditional revenue streams. The competitive landscape in SMB-focused digital payment solutions has intensified with fintech startups gaining market share, making execution of growth strategies critical for future performance. Nevertheless, the persistent insider buying activity represents a positive signal of management's confidence in the company's long-term value proposition. Investors should carefully evaluate whether the substantial gap between current stock price and analyst targets represents genuine upside opportunity or reflects a more realistic market assessment of the company's transformation challenges and growth prospects in an increasingly competitive landscape.

You can receive notifications when news is published.