ESOA

Energy Services ($ESOA) CFO Buys Shares After Quarterly Loss; Stock Surges 13%

05/20/2025 12:48

Energy Services of America Corp ($ESOA) is drawing attention as CFO Charles Crimmel purchased company shares following a disappointing earnings release. According to an SEC Form 4 filing on May 19, Crimmel acquired 500 shares at $9.40 each, totaling $4,700. The timing of this purchase is particularly noteworthy as it comes after a significant stock price decline following disappointing quarterly results. $ESOA is a small-cap engineering and construction services company headquartered in Huntington, West Virginia, providing infrastructure development and maintenance services for natural gas, petroleum, water distribution, automotive, chemical, and power industries. The company primarily operates in the eastern United States, including West Virginia, Virginia, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Kentucky, with a market capitalization of approximately $160 million. According to SEC documents, Crimmel's purchase was executed pursuant to a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, which allows insiders to schedule trades in advance to avoid the appearance of trading on material non-public information. Purchases under 10b5-1 plans are often interpreted as positive signals by investors, as they typically reflect management's confidence in the company's long-term value. The timing of this insider buy is particularly significant because it follows $ESOA's May 12 announcement of a $6.8 million net loss for the second quarter of fiscal 2025. According to the detailed earnings report released on May 13, the company recorded an adjusted loss of $0.41 per share, substantially missing analyst expectations of $0.10 per share profit. Revenue increased 7.8% year-over-year to $76.68 million but fell short of the $80 million market forecast. Following this disappointing earnings announcement, $ESOA's stock plummeted approximately 17%, dropping from $9.9 to $8.23 on May 13. On May 19, the day of Crimmel's purchase, the stock rebounded significantly, climbing 12.98% from $8.40 to $9.49. Examining $ESOA's insider trading patterns reveals interesting trends. Between August and December 2024, several directors, particularly Marshall Reynolds and Frank Lucente, executed substantial sales during periods of stock price appreciation. For instance, Director Marshall Reynolds sold over 150,000 shares between mid-August and late September 2024, while Director Frank Lucente also divested tens of thousands of shares during the same period. In contrast, 2025 has seen a shift toward insider buying. On February 12, Director Mark Prince purchased 21,000 shares at $10.96 per share ($230,160 total), and now the CFO has added to his position. Notably, these purchases have occurred during periods of stock price weakness or decline. From a financial perspective, $ESOA presents mixed signals. The company's trailing twelve-month revenue stands at $367.91 million with net income of $18.23 million, representing a 4.95% profit margin. Earnings per share (TTM) of $1.09 translates to a P/E ratio of 8.71, significantly below the industry average of 15-20. However, the debt-to-equity ratio is high at 98.94%, indicating substantial financial leverage. Wall Street analysts maintain an optimistic outlook on $ESOA. The median 12-month price target stands at $20.00, suggesting approximately 110% upside potential from current levels. The average analyst rating remains a 'buy.' Insider transactions are often considered strong indicators of management's conviction about a company's future. Despite recent disappointing results, the CFO's decision to purchase shares suggests that executive leadership views the quarterly performance shortfall as temporary and maintains confidence in the company's long-term growth prospects. This could signal that despite recent underperformance, positive sentiment persists within the company's leadership, potentially serving as a bullish indicator for investors. This insider buying activity and the stock's sharp rebound suggest $ESOA may have the potential to overcome recent setbacks. However, investors should also consider the high debt levels and the possibility that recent performance challenges could persist.

You can receive notifications when news is published.