53

CBRL

GMT Capital Makes $3.8 Million Bet on Cracker Barrel ($CBRL) After Stock Plunges 50% From 52-Week High

04/09/2025 07:42

Sentiment

Summary

  • GMT Capital purchased 105,900 shares ($3.8 million) of Cracker Barrel ($CBRL) at a time when the stock has fallen approximately 50% from its 52-week high.
  • CBRL's adjusted EPS for the quarter ended January 31, 2025, was $1.38, significantly exceeding expectations of $1.09, prompting Truist to upgrade the stock to a 'buy' rating.
  • Despite challenges including pressure from activist investor Biglari and reduced consumer spending, the company continues to pursue its strategic transformation plans.

POSITIVE

  • Major shareholder GMT Capital made a significant purchase (105,900 shares, $3.8 million) during a period of stock price decline.
  • Recent quarterly earnings significantly exceeded expectations, with adjusted EPS of $1.38.
  • Truist upgraded the stock to 'buy' with a price target of $55.
  • Potential for performance recovery through new menu items and improved service.

NEGATIVE

  • Stock has declined more than 45% year-over-year and almost 60% over five years.
  • Dividend payout ratio of 127% raises questions about sustainability as the company is paying more than it earns.
  • Management uncertainty due to board pressure from activist investor Biglari.
  • Facing structural challenges in the restaurant industry including inflation and reduced consumer spending.

Expert

While the restaurant industry faces dual challenges of inflation and reduced consumer spending, Cracker Barrel's recent earnings improvement and GMT Capital's significant purchase are positive signals. However, the high dividend payout ratio and management uncertainty remain risk factors.

Previous Closing Price

$57.44

-1.30(2.21%)

Average Insider Trading Data Over the Past Year

$40.45

Purchase Average Price

$0

Sale Average Price

$17.2M

Purchase Amount

$0

Sale Amount

Transaction related to News

Trading Date

Filing Date

Insider

Title

Type

Avg. Price

Trans. Value

05/31/2025

05/31/2025

Sale

$

GMT Capital, a major shareholder of Cracker Barrel Old Country Store ($CBRL), has made a significant purchase amid a steep decline in the company's stock price. According to SEC filings, GMT Capital purchased 105,900 shares on April 4 at an average price of $35.94, representing a total investment of approximately $3.8 million. This purchase comes at a time when $CBRL's stock has fallen approximately 50% from its 52-week high of $71.13. Following this transaction, GMT Capital now holds a total of 2,452,200 shares, marking a substantial increase in its position. Despite the complex ownership structure, this large purchase suggests that a major investor sees significant value at the current price levels. Cracker Barrel has been facing challenging times over the past several months. The stock, which had climbed to nearly $65 in late January 2025, has been on a sharp downward trajectory since February and is currently trading in the $35-37 range. This represents a decline of more than 45% year-over-year and almost 60% over the past five years. However, there have been some positive signals in the company's most recent earnings. In results announced on March 6 for the quarter ended January 31, 2025, $CBRL reported adjusted earnings of $1.38 per share, significantly exceeding analysts' expectations of $1.09. Revenue also increased by 1.5% year-over-year to $949.44 million. Following these improved results, Truist upgraded $CBRL to a 'buy' rating on March 10 and set a price target of $55. Truist expressed confidence in sustained improvement due to new menu items and improved service, despite ongoing challenges. Meanwhile, $CBRL has also been facing governance pressure since last August when activist investor Biglari (Lion Fund II) announced its intention to nominate five candidates to the board. The company has responded by affirming its commitment to continuing its strategic transformation plans. For fiscal year 2024, $CBRL reported revenue of $3.47 billion, a modest 0.8% increase from the previous year, with operating income of $45.1 million and net income of $40.9 million. The restaurant chain, which operates 658 locations and employs 77,600 people, has been struggling with the dual challenges of inflation and reduced consumer spending in its post-pandemic recovery. Cracker Barrel currently offers a dividend yield of 2.8%, with a payout ratio of 127%, indicating that the company is paying out more than it earns in dividends, which raises questions about dividend sustainability. While GMT Capital's substantial purchase could be interpreted as a signal that the current stock price is undervalued, investors should consider both the structural challenges facing the restaurant industry and the company's potential for performance recovery. Key factors include how effectively $CBRL can implement its strategic changes in an environment characterized by high prices, reduced consumer spending, and intensified competition. The next quarterly earnings announcement, progress on strategic plans, and developments in the governance issue with Biglari will likely be critical variables determining the future direction of the stock price. Particularly worth monitoring are any additional moves by major investors like GMT Capital regarding their equity positions.

You can receive notifications when news is published.

news-alarmnews-alarm

Sign up and access more data free.

Sign up and access more data free.

  • Access advanced features of insider transaction screener.

  • Read insider transaction news without any limits.