PSEC

Prospect Capital($PSEC) CEO Purchases $70 Million in Shares Over Nine Months, Yet Stock Continues to Struggle as Investor Concerns Mount

03/23/2025 09:42

Over the past nine months, the CEO and top executives of Prospect Capital Corp ($PSEC) have been on an extraordinary share-buying spree. Despite these strong insider buying signals, the stock price has failed to break out of its weakness, capturing investor attention. The business development company (BDC) $PSEC has been experiencing challenging times recently. The stock has been on a downward trend since last August, falling approximately 16% from around $5.00 in early August 2024 to the current $4.22. Notably, on November 8th last year, the stock plummeted from $5.02 to $4.29 in just one day. Amidst this declining stock performance, CEO John F. Barry has purchased over 16 million shares worth approximately $70 million over the past nine months. Specifically, Barry acquired around 6.5 million shares ($34 million) during August-September 2024, about 6 million shares ($27 million) in November, 2 million shares ($8.6 million) on December 24th, and approximately 2.8 million shares ($12 million) in March 2025. COO M. Grier Eliasek has also consistently bought company shares during the same period, accumulating approximately 500,000 shares (worth about $2.5 million), with particularly concentrated purchases of around 450,000 shares during November-December 2024. Additionally, CFO Kristin Lea Van Dask and directors Eugene S. Stark and William Gremp have participated in smaller purchases. All insider transactions were reported as pre-planned trades under SEC Rule 10b5-1. These plans are established by insiders when they don't possess material non-public information, serving as a mechanism to avoid market manipulation allegations. $PSEC specializes in lending to and investing in middle-market companies. According to recent financial data, while the company generated annual revenue of $796.25 million, it recorded a net loss of $91.22 million (or -$0.21 per share), indicating challenges in its investment portfolio. A notable aspect of $PSEC is its high dividend yield. Currently paying annual dividends of $0.63 per share, the stock offers an impressive 14.63% yield at the current price. While this may be attractive to investors, concerns exist about its sustainability. On a positive note, in October 2024, the company expanded its Revolving Credit Facility to over $2.1 billion and extended the maturity to June 2029. This can be viewed as a positive signal for the company's liquidity and operational stability. However, Wall Street's perspective remains relatively negative. The analyst consensus is 'Sell,' with an average price target of $4.50, suggesting only a 4.53% upside from the current price. This contrasts sharply with the strong buying signals from insiders. From a credit rating standpoint, $PSEC holds a BBB- from Egan-Jones, Ba1 from Moody's, and BB+ from S&P, positioning it at the lower end of investment grade or the upper end of speculative grade. This suggests that while the company's financial stability isn't severely concerning, caution is warranted. Examining the relationship between insider buying and stock price movements, the stock rose from $4.9 to $5.2 following the August-September bulk purchases, and partially recovered from $4.1 to $4.6 alongside insider buying after the November plunge. However, the price rebound effect was limited despite the massive purchases in December and March. This pattern of insider buying may signal that management is confident in the company's long-term value and prospects. In particular, the 'cluster buying' pattern, where the CEO and COO participate in purchases consecutively alongside other executives, is generally interpreted as a positive insider signal. However, with the stock price continuously declining and the company recording net losses, it's difficult to determine whether these purchases represent a search for long-term value or short-term measures to defend the stock price. The broader pressures on the BDC sector from interest rate volatility and recession concerns must also be considered. Investors should closely monitor the next earnings announcement scheduled for May 7th. Key points to watch include changes in Net Asset Value (NAV), improvements in portfolio quality, and indicators related to dividend sustainability. The current situation, where aggressive insider buying has had limited impact on stock price rebounds, suggests that the market is demanding clearer evidence of fundamental improvements in the company. Investors should comprehensively consider both the appeal of the high dividend yield and the company's financial health and growth potential.

You can receive notifications when news is published.